Oh heather....got to tell you this: My W decided that we needed to give our DD5 some sort of religious education because she had seen some of her relatives who grew up without any such education, grow into holy rollers. DD5 already goes to an Episcopal day school, and, with my wife a Buddhist, and me a Jew, what do you do? She did the legwork and we ended up going to a UU church (Unitarian/Universalist). I was skeptical. Although I hadn't been a practicing Jew for many years, I was pretty protective of my heritage.
I was "hooked" by the end of the Reverend's first sermon. This is like no other church I'd ever heard of, attended, etc.
All I can say is this 45 year old Jew boy proudly calls himself a member of this "church". (And yes, when I talk about it, I do the "air quotes" when I say "church").
Now may not be the time, but I urge you to go and give it a try.
