JL, do what you feel is right. Obviously you are caught between two opposing theories on how to proceed. RB and I discussed this a few days ago and I ended by saying that I think it's important to try to ride out one method for doing this rather than bounce around because of this very situation. You have two "experts" telling you two totally different things. So, in that case, you just have to do what you think is right and own the outcome. Like it was already suggested, a lot can happen in 6 months...
