I tried Fenugreek to increase my supply, didn't try any other pills, my Dr. didn't suggest any to me and I was hesitant to try something she didn't suggest....nothing much worked for me at all....you'll have to let me know what you used in case we do decide to have another.
I've come to the conclusion that my mistake was with the equipment I tried to use to express milk when not feeding. I, like you, tried everything I could...it can be really frustrating. I loved the time I was able to do that for Ian, nothing quite like that feeling