Originally Posted by "JDevast"
My gut feeling is to validate and give the key back.
Except my gut gut feelings are always to placate her

Maybe, validate without placating her?

Originally Posted by "Revised"
Her: I want your key back to the house.

You: Let me think about it

Her: I only backed down and gave you the key back because It he dog was dying. I knew you wouldn't change, I thought you knew what you had done to me. I let my guard down by giving key back. You haven't changed.

You: My not handing over the keys just now, makes you feel I don't get what harm my years of alcoholism did to you.

Her: I knew I should never have let my guard down. I thought you were working on yourself to realise what you have done to me. It's all an act I thought you had changed.

You: You feel I haven't even been trying to understand how my alcoholism affected you.

Her: I don't trust a word you say.

You: You don't trust my words, only my actions.

Her: I'm not talking to you until you give the key back.

You: I understand. I'll think about it.