Quote
You did address a lot of what I was looking for. In my sitch and I can't believe I am the only one, WW is demonstrating all of the signs of the "Will herself to do the right things" stage. It took a while to trust that it wasn't just to throw me off her trail. But I see it almost exactly as you described your sitch. BTW, I believe this stage deserves a legit Label.


I want to clarify what I mean by doing something from my will, rather than from emotions. People usually have some level of standards by which they conduct their lives. When we are passionate about a right cause, we can dive in with both feet and it's great. That's the easy way. If we don't have the passion but we know it's a right cause, we may still work for it. It's just not as easy without the passion.

In order to "do the right thing", you have to know what the right thing is. Make sense? For me, I knew it was wrong for a M woman to do what I had been doing, and according to my own moral & spiritual beliefs, the right thing started with me ending the A. Did I really want to end the A? I'm embarrassed to say that my emotions were kicking and screaming, "Don't do it, don't do it". But my actions did it. When we do the right action, our emotions will catch up and feel right, too. Yes, actions count a lot more.

When the couple is residing under the same, either as IHS or just sleeping in separate beds, it would be very easy for the WW to try to slide under the bar of H's stipulations of reconciling with her. In other words, she might not want to make a verbal commitment to working on the MR.....much less doing whatever is necessary to save it. From what I have read, the WW is infamous for wanting to tell the H how things will be "if" she decides to reconcile. Some WW's don't want to even give the H a solid answer as to where she stands, and he finds himself playing a guessing game. Rather than plainly coming out with it, she'll say things like, "I'm still here", which should be an unacceptable answer, IMO. If the H has to ask his WW where they currently stand and she gives a response similar to that one......she's not committed. She may want one foot in and one foot out, but she is not committed to doing what she needs to do, coming from the place of betrayal. So, my advice to all the H's is to not consider themselves reconciled or piecing if she won't do better than that.

There may be some exception, but from what I've seen, most WW's who have not reached the point of remorse still have a ton of resentment, and they want to twist the burden of guilt to the H. I've talked about this before, and although he may be eager to show off his skills at being a better H, he really needs to hold her feet to the fire......should she start making it about all his faults before she even lets him know if she's willing to just be willing to work on the M. Some cases where the couple are physically separated and she's suffered loss & consequences due to her choices, she may be ready and willing to what the H needs in order to feel safe in a relationship with her. The disadvantage of living under the same roof is when there has been betrayal and the wayward spouse just wants to seep back as little and as painlessly as possible. I think it certainly applies to the WW who has not yet felt remorse. It took me a while, as a recovering WW, to accept that my actions had been the worst thing done to a MR. I wanted to spotlight my H's faults and make them equally as bad as having an affair. Well, the WW just can't progress with that type of attitude.

Quote
So question is, stubborn W hasn't admitted that she is piecing or staying or anything. I have heard "For now I am still here" but as offten said here, actions speak louder than words. I think due to self esteam issues blah blah blah, she will always struggle to admit how wrong she was.


Well, you know her better than anyone. I'll just put it this way, I don't think a WW is going to "accidently" get to where she needs to be in her MR. There needs to be a conscious decision on her part, or otherwise you risk living together like roommates, at best. As for the self-esteem issues? I think it's pride that prevents people from admitting they were wrong. That's JMHO.

I believe many WW's try to ride the fence b/c they aren't sure they want the want a full relationship with their H.....so she tries to leave the back door open in case she wants out. That's a WW who is not committed, IMHO. I'll admit that I wasn't at sure when I first ended my A. I remember one of my mentors trying to narrow it down, and finally I was asked if I could just end the A and go NC with OM. That was the only thing I was being asked to do. It was hard! But that was me making a decision to do "the right thing" and end the A, despite what I felt. My heart wasn't in it, but I had to handle it just like some other addiction and take it hour by hour, then day by day, etc.

Quote
I do believe she is trying to show me.
Anyway, I don't think the feelings are all back, so she is still Willing herself. And I have tried to be supportive as you described.


How is she trying to show you? Has she gone completely NC with OM? Is she being transparent? And if she hasn't ended things with OM, then why are you be so supportive? See what I mean? If she hasn't ended her A, then your "support" efforts look more like compromising. I need to catch up on your sitch.

Quote
We are doing a lot of this Friendly activity stuff that you described. But telling her that I reqire for her to move back to the MBR seems confrintational. Telling her that sex will be expected seems like fighting words.


Well, that pretty much answers my question. She's still holding out and there has been no obvious statement from her indicating that she has made a decision. See, she keeps you in this guessing field. Look, when I made the decision to do the right thing, I did have a conversation with my H and let him know I had ended the affair, and would be staying in the M, and I became transparent. We even engaged in using a book for guidance for awhile, b/c he wouldn't agree to MC. But there was a conscious decision on my part. No, my feelings had not returned at that point, but there was no question which direction I had decided to go. It took nearly two years for me to get from the point of ending my A to the point of me finally breaking down my pride and sincerely and humbly apologizing to my H and really desiring to make things work. That's when my feelings of love started returning. But let me tell ya, if I had continued contacting OM......my H would not have been my personal cheerleader, playing happy family and acting as my BFF.

Do you see how the WW could be misinterpreted your "support" as meaning you are compromising or settling for whatever crumbs she throws your way? My H was not as tough on me as he should have been. He was not the one on the board getting the tools. But through my own experience, and from reading thousands of other experiences, I am telling you not to settle for her crumbs. She has to do better, but if she isn't getting the information to know what she's dealing with and what to expect, then she's likely not going to go as far with it as needed. She has to start with a decision. See, this is why I hate IHS. The lines are too blurred for the WW and the LBH. You are trying to act as if you are in piecing but you don't know where you are. And, if you don't feel you can tell her what you expect from a wife, then I'm afraid you won't get it. Of course, you don't feel free to lay out those requirements, if she hasn't even let you know anything. Giving her time for the feelings to return is one, but you should know where the M stands rather than trying to convince yourself she is trying, when she isn't.

Quote
So should I find the best way to comunicate the above requirments or continue to be patient?


No, the first thing you do is find out if she's still in contact with OM. Are you sleeping in the same bed with her? Is this still a IHS? If the A ended, then has there been a transparency plan for her? Does she act secretive with her phone and/or don't want you asking her questions? It goes nowhere until she ends things with OM, plain and simple.

I hope I'm wrong, and maybe you can fill me in, but it sounds as if you may have the cart before the horse.
Let me know. I'll be glad to go back and completely redo this post.


It is not about what you feel should work in your M. It is about doing the work that gets the right results. Do what works!