I still think the best one is the first. She's not asking for a yes/no, as I have come to understand it. She's looking for validation. The question doesn't have enough meat on it to help her. You need to dig deeper into the 'why's' of the question.
It's kinda like touching a man o' war... you're going to get stung, regardless. Might as well figure out where she's at, and maybe flank the question to get to what she wants.
That's if you want to touch that poison-laced double spear...
M46, EXWW46 M15 T17 D20, S19, D13 M - Addiction since 1998 W EA/PA #1 2013/2014 W EA #2 June 2015... BD 1 Big D talk 9/15 BD 2 - EA/PA disc 10/30/15 Served D 1/22/16 Divorced 5/25/16 (yes, that fast!)