The catamaran idea sounds like a perfect one! We are heading your way in Jan - Kaui, Maui & Oahu. Josh came with me 2 years ago & just loved it. Ashley is joining us for the last 2 weeks.
I thought Josh was taller by the pic he had posted online but that was my perception. He is taller than me - some things are much more important.
Could your BFF be jealous? 2 dates cannot be imagined. Enjoy the attention!