But what did your W say? Don't be gross. That sounds to me like "sure it happened, but we don't talk about things like that in front of daddy." That to me was more telling than what S5 said.
I went back and realized I left this section out of my re-telling. When S5 said that, I actually got up and started to leave. I reminded her that ONE time I had a conversation with a single girl who was flirty, and I went out of my way to call W and make sure that nothing had been said, I was not interested, and I wanted to make sure no rumors got started. She said to her saying "That's gross" was like saying "There's no way I'd do that".
I told W that S5 would not say that out of the blue, and W said "I have given EA a goodbye hug occasionally, and one time he kissed me on the cheek, and S5 was like 'ooooo'". She was literally standing in my way, begging me to stay at this point.
I dunno. As Arnold Schwarzenegger said, "Where there's smoke, there's fire."
