Regarding the "logic," I think this way.

CV has a hobby of gardening.
CV doesn't ask H to join her anymore.
CV has told H that she enjoys doing it alone and does not want H's participation, much like H and his golf.
CV has asked H to stop asking to join her.

To me, logic dictates that H shouldn't keep asking/complaining about gardening with CV.

Is that illogical?

Would it have been alright if I simply responded, "Yes, that's correct, I don't you to garden with me", and have that be the end of the discussion?


Me:49 WAW H:59
T:19.5 M:19
S:13