...WAKE UP!! Tell her to get her own toothpicks or keep looking for them. She's nuts. OR HANG UP ON HER
Glad I wasn't the only one thinking that, LOL! Toothpicks are what, a dollar for a box of a zillion? That is one of the craziest WAS requests I've heard!
While we're on this subject, when my WAW moved out she took half of everything she could think of down to pouring half the dishwashing soap out of the bottle and taking half the q-tips. She came back later when I wasn't there and took half the firewood off the pile. Still makes me roll my eyes when I think about it!