Oh and possibly another important note is that during the break up conversation, she couldn't stop blushing every time I recounted a good memory or gave her a compliment.
When asked if she had an issue with me, she couldn't answer. When asked if she and I both experienced the feelings we did, she couldn't look me in the eye, and kept saying "I'm sorry, Alamo."
To top it off, she decided not to stay at our church anymore.