I wouldn't have mentioned the ILY - that's bound to put her on the defensive. Then you criticized her for 'not being truthful', further putting her on the defensive.
Trust me brother - I do that ALL the time and don't really see it until later.
On the wedding rings - I've been advised by many to NOT bring it up. My W started wearing them less and less until Bomb time, then not at all. A few weeks ago they disappeared from her jewelry box. I'm assuming she put them in the safe, but I ain't gonna ask her about it!
Me-44, W-38 S12, D10 --- EA: 3/20/11 Bomb: 3/25/11 "I'm waiting til June to 'do something'" statement from W: 4/26/11 Still in same house, in same bed