Funny - I've had the best luck on OKCupid so far! Coffee date guy was from there, oh-so-handsome-and-clever 27 year old is from there. (Who, speaking of which, just contacted me He's been gone home for Xmas and I hadn't heard from him since the 23rd - I was starting to think he'd had his fun with me. Then he contacts me tonight - his grandpa died and the house has been full of relatives in for the funeral etc - just winding down.)
I'm on Match too and I thought perhaps since it was a paid site there would be a better quality of guys there, but I'm not thinking I see any real difference - in fact I see a lot of the same guys on both.