The boundary is not a 5 minute or 2 hour 4 day boundary. IF the results are not monitored and acheived the boundary is enforced.
Your boundary seemed very straightforward to me: "End all contact with OM; I will not live in an open marriage."
The "results" were that she refused.
And you're not enforcing your boundary, other than with WORDS (which actually WEAKENS your hand, not strengthens it).
"Losing weight" is an incremental goal. "I will no longer eat ice cream before I go to bed" is a DECISION, and either it's done each day or it's not. Your wife is refusing to stop eating her ice cream (cake), and thus violating your boundary.
This is foolish, and dangerous. You are allowing the one person in the marriage who DOESN'T have its best interests at heart, to dictate the terms of its potential reconciliation or demise.
And one more thing... controlling comes across in the tone of your posts here.
This is my boundary and you will obey or I am done... again!
Compare that tone to this one:
"Look, you have some great qualities, and we have had some great times, but this whole business of you dating other men just isn't right, and I won't do it anymore, so I took the liberty of getting some boxes and packing some of your stuff up, and ...".
"Anyway, thanks for being so understanding about why this isn't working for me anymore".
M-47,W-40,No kids D-filed 5/27/2010 Piecing - 10/21/2010 -=Soon to be banned=-
And one more thing... controlling comes across in the tone of your posts here.
This is my boundary and you will obey or I am done... again!
Compare that tone to this one:
"Look, you have some great qualities, and we have had some great times, but this whole business of you dating other men just isn't right, and I won't do it anymore, so I took the liberty of getting some boxes and packing some of your stuff up, and ...".
"Anyway, thanks for being so understanding about why this isn't working for me anymore".
I have been kind in my tone with her. I also have told her it isnt punitive, it is just my respect for marriage.
I HAVE NOT CEDED MY BOUNDARY! The point is she KNOWS what the boundary is. I CHOOSE when to enforce it. I am also being patient as a few wise people have recommended and allow the WAW to KNOW I am not controlling her. IF I control her and she senses control... it will be be just like Serenity and Sandi point out, she will simply hide it and go underground. She is doing her Cost/Value/Analysis and if she senses Value and she sees that I am the package like Pookie said, she will come willingly. IF NOT I Force the Boundary. What is a week?
So Time Starsky, and Steve MC, what is the harm in a week? What? Why the alacrity? thoughts? And where are you with your Sitch?
M:42 W:39 S:9 M:20 T:25 D-bomb: 30 Sep 10 Wife changed her mind: 31 Oct 10 Working on it: 31 Oct 10
Um Starsky reread what I wrote... she is not dictating the terms of Reconciliation... she is using her choice to DROP the OM.. that is all.. that is the only thing I am prepared to allow a small amount of time for...
M:42 W:39 S:9 M:20 T:25 D-bomb: 30 Sep 10 Wife changed her mind: 31 Oct 10 Working on it: 31 Oct 10