In my opinion & I believe many courts have ruled this way.. they were a gift and despite whatever symbology you place on them, she is under no legal obligation to return them.
I believe, & my StBX agrees, mine were a gift and mine to do with as I please.
I will take the diamond and have it made it into a necklace for our daughter when she graduates high school. I will sell the gold bands & purchase a watch for our son when he graduates college.
What would you do with them if you get them back?
Peace Bridge
Divorced 03/2010 Mom to two amazing kids
Taking the road less traveled because those encountered on the way may be just as unique.