I agree with your philosophical wanderings here. I see both the pro's and cons of separation from the kids point of view.
Honestly, though, there is another consideration. Me. I look at my kids and I don't want to separate from them. I don't want to miss half of their weekends and half of their birthdays and half of the holidays etc.
Originally Posted By: SmileysPerson
But what about the elusive Middle Ground or Third Way? Is there an intermediate stage for the Thinkers? Separation? Or is that too cost-prohibitive?
Unfortunately, we live in an expensive (but not large or luxurious) house in an expensive area of the country. I have the only real income. Mrs. T works hard at a low paying, but rewarding, part time job in the evenings, and is trying to start a business which takes even more of her time and pays nothing. My income currently pays just enough to pay our mortgage and expenses. Even while receiving a fair alimony from me, she would not be able to afford to either maintain our current house, or rent a house nearby that is big enough for the kids.
The only financially feasible separation would mean me moving to a small inexpensive apartment while she stays in the house with the kids - not a situation I want to be in.
To create a separation realistically simulates the conditions of D, we would have to sell our house.
Me 42, W 39, S8, S6, S2 M 11y, A & ILYBNILWY 11/08 Walking away from a bad situation.