Maybe you should just look around and see if you can find another place. There are great deals out there. When I lived in Chicago ten years ago, my roommate and I found one such deal. In Lakeview, HUGE, nice three bedroom Victorian, second floor with a yard, balcony and garden, $850 per month, heat included. It was a good $400-500 cheaper per month than any comparable place.
Not that it has to be a full-on search, but if you look you might find something good.
Me: 42/H: 37 T: 10 years/M: 8 D9, S8 Bomb: 7.23.07 Separated: 1.20.08 D Final 3.19.09 Affair started in '05, found out parts in 11/07. They married 11.26.09