Yup it is quite a mess. She has done this before and denied it. I have a recordering of a discussion between us where my son says she beat him and she said she did not. He does not want anything to do with her and had to sleep in my bed last night for he was afraid. My S12 is such a wonderful kid. 1 in a million, great athele and very good in school. All of this is starting to slip. What a shame.