You are a good man doing your best in a really really hard place. But what you are doing is not working -right?
So my ideas are: STOP - stop trying to save your marriage, stop trying to fix your wife, stop trying to figure out if you want to be married to W. Its all out of your control.
So what can you do instead?
The words are 'lovingly detach'.
What does that mean? - Firstly you do this because you love yourself, your wife and your kids. You dont do this because you want to 'pay back' or 'teach a lesson'. Detach - meaning to separate yourself from W's anger, drama, tension, upset. You can do this while physically being present (and I agree with your thoughts that you should not be the one to leave at this stage). Detach - withdraw so that you can reserve yourself, so that you can still be true to yourself and be OK. Find your inner mojo!
I know its hard but it will help you a millions times to be happier and more in control of yourself. You dont want to be swayed any longer about what W is thinking or doing. You want to be centered.
Replace all that time and energy that is currently going into worrying about how you are going to fix this mess, you should instead concentrate on you. I know in the start I had to break it up into blocks of 30 minutes. A 30 minute break where I did something I enjoyed.
You know what is really crazy? You are SO great, and W is the one missing out on you - not the other way around. You cant fix her but you can fix yourself so that you can draw her back to being attracted to you.
Essie, Ouch? How long does one have to sit back and watch him spinning like a top? How long does one pussyfoot around? The Man needs to get a grip, get some focus and stick with the program.
There can be no testimony without a test. I am praying to go through this test and come out the other end with a new and better marriage then before.
P.S You are doing great and you should be proud of yourself for even coming to this website and giving DB a go!
P.P.S - Retroville (spelling?) is another from of you trying to fix the relationship. If you ask her to go she will feel pressured, she is unlikely to get much out of it, and then she will have the ultimate excuse of 'I tried everything - BT is the one with the problem'.
Essie, I think I love you! Thanks for the kind words. You are a very strong person and I admire that in you.
BND: I agree with some of the stuff you are saying, I am ready for you. What do you suggest at this point, what am I doing wrong that I can correct today.
Tonight has been great so far. Been sitiing and talking like human beings and everything. W made a wonderful dinner and 2 out of my 3 boys eat very calmly with us. AMAZING. Are these baby steps?