What if you have 10 women in a room who all take care of themselves, all look fairly good and wear nice perfumes. What will make the difference?
First of all, someone kill me right there if this scenario comes up -- it doesn't get much better than that (esp if they are all competing for my attention)!
Seriously though, I'll try to come back in a little bit and respond to your posts -- I don't want to just slap something down and call it good (I don't have time for a very thought-out post right now).
However, for the record, the answer for the post directly above this one will have to do with what each individual guy likes. I can likely only post what interests me, and therefore can't speak for the collective whole.
