Divorcebusting.com  |  Contact      
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 2 of 5 1 2 3 4 5
Joined: Nov 2019
Posts: 491
Likes: 9
S
Member
Offline
Member
S
Joined: Nov 2019
Posts: 491
Likes: 9
Josh,

I could have written a lot of your first post. All these situations rhyme.

James Dobson wrote Love Must Be Tough - he is with Focus on the Family and some of the book helped me wrap my head around the fact that if a spouse leaves us, we will not be held accountable. That was a big deal for my mindset. 1 Corinthians 7:15 - I think this passage gives you a degree of clearance to go and live in peace. Consider getting that book at the library to skim through.

A book that my counselor referred to me (I go every other week and though I don't like it, I think its healthy when dealing with this situation) was Heartbreak, Mourning, Loss by Ginette Paris. Its short and quick and helped me understand the stages of heartbreak I was going through and began to give me tools to work through it.

My divorce will be final 2/28/2022. I've got two kids caught in the middle and I'm 43. If you WAW is gone, consider finding a way to make peace with it.

And funny enough, the only way to possibly get her back is to move forward.

Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 17
L
lost___ Offline OP
New Member
OP Offline
New Member
L
Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 17
Originally Posted by SteveLW
Joshua, I am so sorry for what you have been through. I can relate so much to it and can empathize completely. It must be a tough time and it has gone on for a while it sounds like. So please, first take some deep breaths and try to slow down and relax a bit. You've probably been running at this at 100 mph since it all started.

First, do not blame MC or the MC for their methods. MC NEVER works with a spouse that is not committed to it. Even if the MC had given you actions and homework, more than likely she would have refused to do it. Her heart wasn't in it. Your MC probably detected very early on that she had 1 and 1/2 fee out of the door and realized that "actionable steps" were futile. Most LBSs immediately jump to MC to try to save the marriage, but the truth is that once the D bomb is dropped, it is too late for MC.

Good to know. I wish the MC would have been a little more upfront with me if they thought that. I got those vibes from the very first session that my spouse wasn't invested, but I was holding out hope. The D bomb wasn't dropped until the end of the 4 months of counseling, but the implication was there way before we even started MC, which is why I was in panic mode throughout the whole thing and basically did everything the DR book says not to do. Wish I had had this book before all this.

Quote
I also detect a bit of Nice Guy, I don't deserve this thinking. I would recommend reading No More Mr. Nice Guy. NGS is not a healthy way to approach relationships and other people. You might find the book useful for your go forward.

I've had this on my list to read so I will check it out. Without having read it, though, I wouldn't necessarily say I have NGS from what I've heard generally about it. Definitely let way too many things slide in the relationship that were generally unacceptable though.

Quote
As far as what you do, well, the question I have is how patient do you want to be? You've waited over a year so far, how long are you willing to wait? Likely she is dating and seeing other people, probably the AP. The fact that you keep reaching out tells her "I can get Joshua back any time I want to." Plan B is not a fun thing to be. So my recommendation is to remove yourself as Plan B, that starts by NOT contacting her anymore.

I'm at the end of my rope, unfortunately. It's been a year and we've talked all of maybe 3 times over the past year. The only way to completely remove myself as plan B is to get the divorce. But I still want to try to snap her out of the divorce trap, but I don't realistically think its going to happen coming from me. Like I said though, due to religious convictions I have not dated anyone and I really want to get on with my life in this area.

Quote
Then you go out a live an awesome life. That is why the DBing advice is to GAL. GAL is your top priority right now. You do not do it to try to get her back, or to show her, you just go live your awesome life. If she takes note through friends and family, great. If not, great to that too! Then you keep working on you. Become the best version of yourself that you can. You tried MC. I would suggest instead IC. Get a good IC and go to work on becoming the best Joshua you can be! And then you have to work on emotional detachment. Detaching emotionally from what she does or doesn't do, what she says or doesn't say is the goal here. The goal is that if she never reaches out to you again, great. If she does, that is ok too, but you will remain emotionally even through all of it!

I know GAL is for me and not for her, but unfortunately GAL will ultimately not be noticed by her. I dont have any contact with her friends or family, and she started cutting me out of her life before she physically separated. She's already moved on and has most likely erased me from her memory.

Quote
Finally, one thing that helped me in my sitch was to set a drop dead date. A date that if she didn't recommit back to the marriage, and hadn't filed for D herself, then I would go file for D and move forward with my life! I highly suggest that for you. I set it 1 year past BD, but your situation is a bit different. How much longer are you willing to wait? A month? 6 months? A year? Figure that out, set a drop dead date, and when that date come you go file for D.

I'm pretty much at the point where if she shows no interest in the slightest, I am not going to commit any more effort in trying to get her to stay. But part of moving on with my life is the need to be divorced. I have given it as much time as I can. The only way I would commit more time to it is if, through some last resort, she showed an interest in keeping the marriage together. Thats why I am trying to gather ideas to approach her before telling her to go ahead and file.

Quote
One red flag I do is is that she was awfully young when she was in a serious committed relationship. If my math is right she was 20 when you started dating? 22-23 when you got married. That is very young especially in today's world. She has a lot of maturing to do, and she may wake up one day and realize that she walked away from the best dude she ever knew. Or she may just move on and never look back. Life is short though, and I would highly suggest you do not wait for her for too long. I am 53. 34-53 flew by! So decide how long you are willing to wait, then realize you did all you could do and move forward with your life.

Perhaps. But she also led me on to believe she was way more emotionally intelligent than she turned out to be. There were a lot of other red flags other than age that I dismissed to my own demise. Definitely a life lesson for me.

Quote
Finally, understand that you will be ok. We have a sticky thread here entitled, You Will Not Die. Please read it. There is life even after D.

Thanks so much for your response! smile

Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 17
L
lost___ Offline OP
New Member
OP Offline
New Member
L
Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 17
Originally Posted by LH19
Josh,

Ok so I am going to be honest with you here. First and foremost it takes two to make a marriage work and right now she is not onboard and there is absolutely nothing you can do to change her mind right now.

You have been separated for a year and a half with no movement so I think you have to ask yourself how long can I wait on her.

Lastly, it sounds like you want kids and sacrificed that for her. That is a really big decision you need to think about. The could lead to major regrets down the road.

Really think about those things and we can help you with whatever direction you decide.

Thanks so much LH19. Yes, with the no kids thing it might be a blessing in disguise. But I really hate the thought of having to try to build a life with someone else from scratch and as others who have been through divorce, I'm sure they are with me in feeling robbed of the many years that could have been spent on someone who would actually have been faithful.

I'm definitely not going to wait on her any longer if she is not interested. But I do want to try one last time to snap her out of it, however that may be. If she shows an interest in actually working on the marriage, I can wait a bit longer. But none of the strategies in DB/DR are useful because of the current relationship dynamic. It would be different if we had any face to face contact, spent any time together, etc but we don't. If she wants a divorce, I am going to tell her to go file and it will be on her, even though its not what I want.

Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 17
L
lost___ Offline OP
New Member
OP Offline
New Member
L
Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 17
Originally Posted by Traveler
Some people are not a good fit for each other. You say you didn't enjoy her company as she was--you wanted her to change and sacrifice to fulfill your needs. One of the more useful exercises a marriage counselor had me and my ex do was list down all the NEEDS we were asking our partners to fulfill. The MC's point was there shouldn't be so many! Have you now figured out how to satisfy most of your needs yourself, or are you struggling without a partner?

My needs were actually quite basic I feel and completely normal. I wanted to grow in intimacy with my spouse - emotionally, physically, and spiritually. Even Michele says in her book that a marriage without sexual intimacy is doomed (Overcoming Passion Meltdown chapter). Like I said, she compartmentalized me to fit me into her life. Me nor the marriage were ever a priority. I tried to bring these up as issues and she stonewalled me constantly. Interestingly enough, she wrote me one letter before she moved out (in which she confessed to kissing AP...I think purely out of guilt), but in it she stated that "I (being the OP) dont ask for much". Really my desire was to have a normal healthy marriage. I didn't ask for that much in the relationship. But I guess it was still too much for her. In marriage, I was seeking someone to be my best friend... for life. She was that person before we got married but then came the bait and switch.

Quote
A starting point might be identifying and owning your mistakes. She owns her affair, but defining your wife as "unpleasable" puts the onus for the broken marriage that preceded it on her as well. By this I don't mean a hand-waving, "Blame is usually 50/50" or "I didn't value what I had". Where did you go wrong? What have you been consistent doing differently since? This sort of introspection and self-improvement helps get back together and helps move on.

I mean, the only thing I can thing of is to approach her and apologize for pressuring her after she separated and ask what I need to change for her to think about recommitting to working on our marriage. But even that to me feels like its more cheese-less tunnel eg continuing to pursue her.

Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 17
L
lost___ Offline OP
New Member
OP Offline
New Member
L
Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 17
Originally Posted by ScottB
Josh,

I could have written a lot of your first post. All these situations rhyme.

James Dobson wrote Love Must Be Tough - he is with Focus on the Family and some of the book helped me wrap my head around the fact that if a spouse leaves us, we will not be held accountable. That was a big deal for my mindset. 1 Corinthians 7:15 - I think this passage gives you a degree of clearance to go and live in peace. Consider getting that book at the library to skim through.

A book that my counselor referred to me (I go every other week and though I don't like it, I think its healthy when dealing with this situation) was Heartbreak, Mourning, Loss by Ginette Paris. Its short and quick and helped me understand the stages of heartbreak I was going through and began to give me tools to work through it.

My divorce will be final 2/28/2022. I've got two kids caught in the middle and I'm 43. If you WAW is gone, consider finding a way to make peace with it.

And funny enough, the only way to possibly get her back is to move forward.

Thank you for the book recommendations. And my conscience is clear before God. I will check them both out. But yea, it does seem like the best path forward is to move on.

Joined: Feb 2017
Posts: 9,227
Likes: 309
L
Member
Offline
Member
L
Joined: Feb 2017
Posts: 9,227
Likes: 309
Josh,

I can promise you one thing you definitely are not going to snap her out of it. You either need to put your life on hold and wait it out or do the filing and move on with your life. If it clears your conscience you can have one more your either in or you’re out convos. I had to start all over again at 50 and two kids so for you it will be even easier. Sometimes these things just don’t work out and you learn from your mistakes and move on.

Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 17
L
lost___ Offline OP
New Member
OP Offline
New Member
L
Joined: Jan 2022
Posts: 17
Originally Posted by LH19
Josh,

I can promise you one thing you definitely are not going to snap her out of it. You either need to put your life on hold and wait it out or do the filing and move on with your life. If it clears your conscience you can have one more your either in or you’re out convos. I had to start all over again at 50 and two kids so for you it will be even easier. Sometimes these things just don’t work out and you learn from your mistakes and move on.

Thanks for the brutal truth. I’m so sorry you had to start over at 50. I do realize some people have it off way worse than me. I truly think divorce is one of the most evil non-violent things one person could do to their spouse, assuming that person was faithful to them

Joined: Jun 2019
Posts: 4,627
Likes: 71
T
Member
Offline
Member
T
Joined: Jun 2019
Posts: 4,627
Likes: 71
Originally Posted by Joshua
I think there are some people you just can't please and my wife is one of them. I sacrificed and compromised a lot for her in the marriage, but she could never reciprocate and was unwilling to fulfill my needs
I know you told Steve you don't think you have Nice Guy Syndrome, but that sounds like it to a T.

Originally Posted by Traveler
Some people are not a good fit for each other. You say you didn't enjoy her company as she was--you wanted her to change and sacrifice to fulfill your needs. One of the more useful exercises a marriage counselor had me and my ex do was list down all the NEEDS we were asking our partners to fulfill. The MC's point was there shouldn't be so many! Have you now figured out how to satisfy most of your needs yourself, or are you struggling without a partner?

Originally Posted by Joshua
My needs were actually quite basic I feel and completely normal. I wanted to grow in intimacy with my spouse - emotionally, physically, and spiritually. Even Michele says in her book that a marriage without sexual intimacy is doomed.
Wanting sex is normal. Different women enjoy sex daily, weekly, or monthly. I'm hearing the frequency worked for you for 2.5yrs, you got married, then it dropped off. Immediately? What changed--i.e., your living situation, your expectations for her, or how often you took her out on a romantic date? Sex doesn't usually drop off after 2.5yrs without kids.

Originally Posted by Traveler
A starting point might be identifying and owning your mistakes. She owns her affair, but defining your wife as "unpleasable" puts the onus for the broken marriage. By this I don't mean a hand-waving, "Blame is usually 50/50" or "I didn't value what I had". Where did you go wrong? What have you been consistent doing differently since? This sort of introspection and self-improvement helps get back together and helps move on.

Originally Posted by Joshua
I mean, the only thing I can thing of is to approach her and apologize.. and ask what I need to change.. that to me feels like its more cheese-less tunnel
You have no idea what your role was in the marriage's demise?!

This is a standard question when dating.

Originally Posted by Steve
Get a good IC and go to work on becoming the best Joshua you can be!
You didn't respond to Steve's point about an IC. Especially if you have no idea where you went wrong, an IC would be a great investment. You don't want to repeat what just happened with her or anyone else. (You don't want to ruminate ad infinitum, either. There's a balance to introspection vs. moving forward with your life.) Your story is almost entirely about her faults.

Joined: Feb 2018
Posts: 9,829
Likes: 240
S
Member
Offline
Member
S
Joined: Feb 2018
Posts: 9,829
Likes: 240
Originally Posted by Traveler
Originally Posted by Joshua
I think there are some people you just can't please and my wife is one of them. I sacrificed and compromised a lot for her in the marriage, but she could never reciprocate and was unwilling to fulfill my needs
I know you told Steve you don't think you have Nice Guy Syndrome, but that sounds like it to a T.

Originally Posted by Traveler
Some people are not a good fit for each other. You say you didn't enjoy her company as she was--you wanted her to change and sacrifice to fulfill your needs. One of the more useful exercises a marriage counselor had me and my ex do was list down all the NEEDS we were asking our partners to fulfill. The MC's point was there shouldn't be so many! Have you now figured out how to satisfy most of your needs yourself, or are you struggling without a partner?

Originally Posted by Joshua
My needs were actually quite basic I feel and completely normal. I wanted to grow in intimacy with my spouse - emotionally, physically, and spiritually. Even Michele says in her book that a marriage without sexual intimacy is doomed.
Wanting sex is normal. Different women enjoy sex daily, weekly, or monthly. I'm hearing the frequency worked for you for 2.5yrs, you got married, then it dropped off. Immediately? What changed--i.e., your living situation, your expectations for her, or how often you took her out on a romantic date? Sex doesn't usually drop off after 2.5yrs without kids.

Originally Posted by Traveler
A starting point might be identifying and owning your mistakes. She owns her affair, but defining your wife as "unpleasable" puts the onus for the broken marriage. By this I don't mean a hand-waving, "Blame is usually 50/50" or "I didn't value what I had". Where did you go wrong? What have you been consistent doing differently since? This sort of introspection and self-improvement helps get back together and helps move on.

Originally Posted by Joshua
I mean, the only thing I can thing of is to approach her and apologize.. and ask what I need to change.. that to me feels like its more cheese-less tunnel
You have no idea what your role was in the marriage's demise?!

This is a standard question when dating.

Originally Posted by Steve
Get a good IC and go to work on becoming the best Joshua you can be!
You didn't respond to Steve's point about an IC. Especially if you have no idea where you went wrong, an IC would be a great investment. You don't want to repeat what just happened with her or anyone else. (You don't want to ruminate ad infinitum, either. There's a balance to introspection vs. moving forward with your life.) Your story is almost entirely about her faults.

This. That quote traveler quoted was the exact line I was referring to when I said I was detecting Nice Guy tendencies. Get and read the book. It has the chance of changing your life.

If I were you, IC would not be optional but mandatory.


M(53), W(54),D(19)
M-23, T-25 Bomb Drop - Dec.23, 2017
Ring and Piecing since March 2018
Joined: Jul 2020
Posts: 1,760
Likes: 193
B
Member
Offline
Member
B
Joined: Jul 2020
Posts: 1,760
Likes: 193
Joshua,

Very sorry you're in this situation. We all know it well here and will gladly lend you support and advice.

Originally Posted by Joshua
From the get-go, I'm fairly certain my spouse had already made up her mind that she wanted to get out of the marriage, so her commitment to working through our problems was nonexistent. I think she just went to try to feel better about herself and absolve her of her guilt.
This is very common. My ExW went to 3 sessions before saying she wanted a divorce. Your W could've done it due to guilt, or perhaps more selfishly because she wanted to be able to tell her friends and family you two "even tried marriage counseling".

Originally Posted by Joshua
she said she wanted to divorce and sent me papers to sign. I didn't sign them. I don't know why she hasn't filed and had me served (I have theories), but we are a year out from that and have no contact.
Have you consulted a L yet? You may want to, though with no children and a relatively short marriage the support is minimal to nothing. Not sure if your incomes or assets would be a factor.

Originally Posted by Joshua
I have tried several times to reach out to her but she is not interested in reconciling.
Time to stop. You've reached out; she's not interested (at least currently). No amount of you reaching out will all of a sudden convince her. You need to go live your life and making it incredible, and maybe she'll reach back out to you.

Originally Posted by Joshua
But I think there are some people you just can't please and my wife is one of them. I sacrificed and compromised a lot for her in the marriage, but she could never reciprocate and was unwilling to fulfill my needs (paraphrasing what my counselor said).

I think it's impossible for a marriage to survive when one of the spouses is just entirely uncommitted to making the marriage and their spouse their priority. It kills friendships, trust, communication, and intimacy. This is all I was ever trying to build with my spouse, but she stonewalled me the entire marriage and things like her parents, her friends, and her AP were way more important than me or the marriage
One of thing things our MC said to me when I called her back after the session my then-W finally admitted to the affair and that she wanted a D is "You should think about what it says about you that you'd want someone in your life who betrayed you." I think about that a lot. To me I was trying to save my marriage and family and didn't want my kids to go through a divorced life, but looking back I was almost certainly acting out of fear for myself as well about being a failure in marriage and not finding someone else. Time has given me a lot more perspective there. So I ask you a similar question...in the ways your describe your W not meeting your needs and making everything but you the priority...what about all that makes you want to keep her in your life?

Originally Posted by Joshua
She tried to compartmentalize me to fit into her life and I, predictably, resented her for it and reacted to her in unhealthy ways. I totally admit that.
This is a good area to explore both on your own and with an IC.

Originally Posted by Joshua
Im 34, she's 27, so a bit of an age gap.

We were together for around 2.5 years before marriage, now 4.5 years married but she moved out and separated after 3.

No children. She never wanted them and I never pressured her, but it added to physical intimacy problems
This may not be comforting at the moment, and I don't mean to make light of your situation because I completely understand how difficult this whole process is, but with your (relatively) young age and no children it's going to be much easier for your to detach, GAL, and not be tied to someone for the rest of your life (as with kids). At some point down the road you'll appreciate that you found out about her infidelity and it broke off before you had children.

Originally Posted by SteveLW
First, do not blame MC or the MC for their methods. MC NEVER works with a spouse that is not committed to it. Even if the MC had given you actions and homework, more than likely she would have refused to do it. Her heart wasn't in it. Your MC probably detected very early on that she had 1 and 1/2 fee out of the door and realized that "actionable steps" were futile.
This is very true. MC was never going to fix it because she was in lala land with AP and did not want it to be fixed. In the just 3-4 sessions we had my MC gave us small homework like "hug once after work" and "watch a move together" and my now-ExW wouldn't do any of it. She was checking the box to ease her guilt or tell her friends and family she "even tried counseling"...or whatever, but the result was predetermined regardless of the counselor's methods.

Originally Posted by SteveLW
Then you go out a live an awesome life. That is why the DBing advice is to GAL. GAL is your top priority right now. You do not do it to try to get her back, or to show her, you just go live your awesome life. If she takes note through friends and family, great. If not, great to that too! Then you keep working on you. Become the best version of yourself that you can. You tried MC. I would suggest instead IC. Get a good IC and go to work on becoming the best Joshua you can be! And then you have to work on emotional detachment. Detaching emotionally from what she does or doesn't do, what she says or doesn't say is the goal here. The goal is that if she never reaches out to you again, great. If she does, that is ok too, but you will remain emotionally even through all of it![quote=SteveLW]
^^^Ding ding ding! Well said. Go out an GAL and make your life awesome.

Originally Posted by LH19
Ok so I am going to be honest with you here. First and foremost it takes two to make a marriage work and right now she is not onboard and there is absolutely nothing you can do to change her mind right now.

You have been separated for a year and a half with no movement so I think you have to ask yourself how long can I wait on her.

Lastly, it sounds like you want kids and sacrificed that for her. That is a really big decision you need to think about. The could lead to major regrets down the road.

Really think about those things and we can help you with whatever direction you decide.
^^^Another great post.

Originally Posted by ScottB
James Dobson wrote Love Must Be Tough - he is with Focus on the Family and some of the book helped me wrap my head around the fact that if a spouse leaves us, we will not be held accountable. That was a big deal for my mindset. 1 Corinthians 7:15 - I think this passage gives you a degree of clearance to go and live in peace.
I second ScottB's recommendation. It's a good book and very relevant to your situation and what I can gather on your faith from your posts.

Originally Posted by Joshua
The D bomb wasn't dropped until the end of the 4 months of counseling, but the implication was there way before we even started MC, which is why I was in panic mode throughout the whole thing and basically did everything the DR book says not to do. Wish I had had this book before all this.
You're not alone. We all made mistakes here. I did the classic begging and pleading and trying to make nice in the midst of an AP and IHS for months. The only thing any of us can do is learn from it and improve for the future.

Originally Posted by Joshua
I'm at the end of my rope, unfortunately. It's been a year and we've talked all of maybe 3 times over the past year. The only way to completely remove myself as plan B is to get the divorce. But I still want to try to snap her out of the divorce trap, but I don't realistically think its going to happen coming from me. Like I said though, due to religious convictions I have not dated anyone and I really want to get on with my life in this area.
You don't necessarily have to file for D or date to remove yourself as Plan B. Resist any attempts to reach out "one more time". Start focusing on you, go out and have fun. You're not going to be able to snap her out of it. She has to come to that realization on her own. I respect the not dating. I refused to date before the D was finalized, which was a year and a half after BD and nearly a year after physical separation. I felt it was the right thing for me morally, the best thing for my kids, and gave me time to work through the process emotionally.

Originally Posted by Joshua
There were a lot of other red flags other than age that I dismissed to my own demise. Definitely a life lesson for me.
What were they?

Originally Posted by Joshua
I'm definitely not going to wait on her any longer if she is not interested. But I do want to try one last time to snap her out of it, however that may be. If she shows an interest in actually working on the marriage, I can wait a bit longer.
Don't do this. It's only going to set you back. You've tried more than once over the last year and a half and she hasn't reciprocated. If she wants to reconcile she'll reach out.

Originally Posted by Joshua
If she wants a divorce, I am going to tell her to go file and it will be on her, even though its not what I want.
Don't do this. You can't make her file, and telling her "it's on her" is passive-aggressive.

Originally Posted by Joshua
I mean, the only thing I can thing of is to approach her and apologize for pressuring her after she separated and ask what I need to change for her to think about recommitting to working on our marriage. But even that to me feels like its more cheese-less tunnel eg continuing to pursue her.
Don't do this. You're suggesting apologizing for pressuring her and then want to ask her what you need to do to get her to reconsider committing to the marriage, which in and of itself is pressure and pursuit.


Hang in there Joshua and keep posting. There are a lot of folks here who have experienced what you're going through and glad to give their time to help.


Me:39 Ex-W:37
M:7 T: 9
S:6 D:3
BD/IHS/Confirm EA/PA: Feb '20
OM1 affair ends: May '20
W/OM2 & moves out: June-July '20
W files for D: Jul20
OM2 confirmed: 9/2020
Divorced: May '21
Page 2 of 5 1 2 3 4 5

Moderated by  Cadet, DnJ, job, Michele Weiner-Davis 

Link Copied to Clipboard
Michele Weiner-Davis Training Corp. 1996-2025. All rights reserved.
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5