Wow, S13, thanks for the post... You didn't write too much... You reinforced what I felt like I was seeing in him...
It felt like a glimpse into his real inner mind... and it's interesting that you say anger/rage was your emotion when your H divulged OW...
And, yes, I DO believe the emotions are 10X over "normal". By definition, the highs are higher and the lows are lower, at least as I understand it...
His coping methods, the anger, were so similar to how he acted before his behavior came under control through a combination of meds, diet, and his own sheer will power...
This has been my instinct:
Quote:
Please allow your son (within reason) to show his emotions, to express his anger and hurt and disappointment in his Mom....Please don't make him keep a lid on what he is feeling otherwise, it will consume him...
... which is why his destruction didn't concern me (except when directed at his siblings) and perhaps why I was so p.o.'ed that W was trying to "logic" him out of his feelings and "flip" things on him...
Thank you for sharing your experiences. I appreciate it...
New: What a Weekend
H-48 WAW-49 M-22 S-14,9 D-11 EA disc.-11/07 PA disc.-3/08 EA2?-6/08 to ?
The "scenes" I wrote about above mostly took place on Friday...
Saturday was more of the same…
Somehow I kept being accused of feeding S14 the thoughts he was coming up with independently (yet which did echo my thoughts). He was upset that W didn’t think he had a mind of his own. So, one of two things is true, he’s either much more perceptive than I ever gave him credit for or her self-interest/selfishness is that much more apparent than she would have it.
I made the mistake of admitting to the boys that my feelings were hurt that D11 offered to help Mommy decorate in the basement. The moment I said it, I wished I could take it back. It was in the context of telling them I wanted them to express their feelings and was meant to serve as an example not to point the finger... Swing and a miss. My bad.
The moment I said it I knew I had blown it. I realized right away that it could fuel S14’s fire. Bad call on my part. When we got back to the house S14 lit into D11 for helping Mommy and she broke down in tears.
Of course, that only fueled W’s ire, too; and, in this case, rightfully so; just as I am doing my best to protect children, so too is she doing her [thought-bubble" misguided] best.
So emotions are revved up again; W and S14 started going at it again, or, more accurately, S14 started into W about her selfishness… She hunkered down into defense mode and again accused me of planting ideas in his head, this time “selfishness”. She was still reeling from his letter and emotions were raw. She was defending herself to him and saying how she’d been selfless for the entire 14 years of his life when I didn’t even have the time for him… and that she wasn’t the selfish one… and how I was blaming her for everything… and how I just loved the fact that S14 was saying what he was because it echoed my thoughts… and how I didn’t care about anyone but myself.
She strode out of the kitchen muttering to all, see this is why you should divorce me, I can’t do anything right in your eyes. I had had it at this point. I reminded her that it was she who was divorcing me; she scoffed at that and I could NOT stand the hypocrisy anymore. I said something to the effect that how could she be trying to butter them up like this (more on this later) and, no, I’m not the one that’s all about me. She’s the one who had the affairs.
In all candor, I don’t feel badly about saying that out loud and I don’t think it registered with any of the children as not one of them has said anything about it since (while a lot of other ground has been covered and re-covered). Somewhere in there there was also the projected accusation of me being the controlling one in our R…
New: What a Weekend
H-48 WAW-49 M-22 S-14,9 D-11 EA disc.-11/07 PA disc.-3/08 EA2?-6/08 to ?
Whew! Bad scene, Alex. But you know that. And yes, I do believe in not shielding the kids from the difficulties of relationships, after all, it's their destiny too. But I still remember how bad it is to be the people in that house where the fight is going on.
Family counseling might be helpful. Get them all in there. Have someone to moderate, to get the feelings out without all the animosity. Your wife may have a pretty exterior, but what's harbored inside is not good-looking. And apparently she is so desperate to get her way that she is using a scorched earth approach. Doesn't work in families.
If she won't go, make the appointment, and herd all the kids in with you. Let her be left out if she so chooses. But get some professional insight.
So, to explain my reference to "buttering up" in the last post...
Fridays events included “Scene 6” above…
Quote:
Scene 6: W gives each child a handwritten "journal" with stories of them as babies and how their names were chosen and the other names we were considering for each of them. It has inspirational messages to them. It’s a beautiful gesture, but why this day of all days? S14 sees right through it and after reading 2 pages throws it to the floor and tells W that it's nothing but an "attempt to make her feel better about her selfish choice". He's relentless, but in a very ugly way.
So, my reference to “buttering up” (admittedly not the best choice of words) was in reference to these “journals” and her passages to the kids saying this had been a long time coming and adult-problems that had been brewing for many years and how she had “tried” and we just couldn’t connect anymore. Yes, she is entitled to those feelings, but some background is in order…
A few weeks back, I had sent her the following e-mail, trying to explain why these types of references felt dishonest to me…
Quote:
I’ve been reading about in a book called “The Truth about Children and Divorce”, by Robert Emery. I haven’t thought about it long enough to know whether or not I agree with his approach, but some of the passages struck home concerning one of the issues I think about… As a gentle reminder, despite what you may believe, I don’t blame your infidelity (nor have I ever) for where we are, but it is part of the story. Emery talks about this topic in a section about what to say to children when affairs have taken place…
“Affairs are often the immediate precipitants of a separation and the kindling of an angry divorce… even when … you and your ex disagree about whether the affair was the whole problem (which I don’t say) or merely a symptom of a longstanding problem in your marriage…”
“If you are in the (betrayed spouse’s) shoes, you may be understandably unwilling to tell the children the reason … is that ‘Mom and Dad are not happy being married.’ One problem with this explanation is that it seems dishonest – unless you take the whole history of the marriage into account, and that’s far beyond what (the children) need to know, want to know, or could possibly understand…”
This passage captures how I feel. That type of explanation feels “dishonest” and rings hollow… Emery goes on to suggest that the “walk-away” spouse divulge the affair (in an age-appropriate way) to the children because it is a “part of the story”whether or not both spouses agree on its significance.
“What can parents agree to say that is honest, acceptable to both of them, and does not go into inappropriate detail?... The admission… is not likely to solve a lot of problems… but… it can be a small step in the right direction…”
Maybe we can talk about this with our ICs when we meet as a group. The book also says…
“A parent’s admission of about (her) affair is likely to be extremely difficult, and the children may well become upset and angry with that parent… So why tell the children? Honesty… This is a chance to be honest – with the children, with your former partner, with yourself. Why else? Reality… Any other reasons? Respect… If you do not want to divorce your children as well as your spouse, you will need a plan to rebuild your relationship with them…”
We subsequently met with our ICs together in an attempt to “script” what to tell the children and talked about this very topic. We agreed not to talk about a history of adult problems and references to her having tried because it felt dishonest to me and BECAUSE this should be about assuring them that it isn't their fault and that we love them and that we will be there for them, but separately; yet, here she was doing exactly what we had agreed NOT to do in the context of telling the children.
So, yes, I was rather taken aback by the journals which contained the very thoughts from which we had agreed to steer clear of with both of our respective ICs present.
New: What a Weekend
H-48 WAW-49 M-22 S-14,9 D-11 EA disc.-11/07 PA disc.-3/08 EA2?-6/08 to ?
I don't understand your point of view here. I see the journals as her trying to reassure the kids that she loves them. I also see them as "parting gifts". Which doesn't make sense, since she isn't moving out right away, so why give them parting gifts now. But understood your agreement to be to leave out the part about the affair, I don't see what that has to do with journals.
However, I do think the journals were extremely poorly timed. I have a feeling that your wife is planning to walk away from the whole family, not just you. Although she certainly seems to single you out for her invective. But the scorched earth policy, not caring what she says in front of the kids, or how she antagonizes everyone speaks to her not planning to maintain a relationship with anyone, except perhaps her little girl.
OK, reading back I see the story of the marriage and adult problems in the journals. I was focusing on the part about each kid. I was thinking of the journals as being like the childhood picture books that I tried to do for each kid. (Only the first kid's book looks decent.) Yes, it's in there.
Why do you focus on her not keeping a small agreement? You should expect her to lie. Cheaters lie. They do not keep their word. She is self-indulgent and will do what she wants at all times. You are not going to control her. whether she makes an agreement with you or not, she is not going to abide by anything she tells you.
OK, reading back I see the story of the marriage and adult problems in the journals. I was focusing on the part about each kid. I was thinking of the journals as being like the childhood picture books that I tried to do for each kid. (Only the first kid's book looks decent.) Yes, it's in there.
Why do you focus on her not keeping a small agreement? You should expect her to lie. Cheaters lie. They do not keep their word. She is self-indulgent and will do what she wants at all times. You are not going to control her. whether she makes an agreement with you or not, she is not going to abide by anything she tells you.
Sara,
You are correct... It's something Puppy always says, too: Cheaters lie. Period.
My intent was not to focus on this issue, but to clarify the comment I made to her, which was but a small part of the scenes from a weekend. It was, in a sense, the straw that broke the camel's back, but, yes, I should not have expected any differently from her... Her failure to live up to this "agreement" pales in comparison to the way she is handling the kids, especially S14.
I just posted something on another thread that I think is relevant to my mindset now with respect to "the big picture" and, in a way, your point:
Quote:
Originally Posted By: Puppy Dog Tails
Clark,
You appear to be equating "holding the walkaway accountable" with "bitterness." I agree that sometimes that's the case, but it isn't ALWAYS the case.
It's possible to fully hold them accountable, as adults who made a marriage vow (contract), and not hold bitterness in one's heart toward them...
Puppy
PDT/Clark,
I think it is possible to do both, too...
In my sitch, I hold W accountable for her affair(s) (but take my share of accountability for an R that made her vulnerable to an affair).
But today, I do have bitterness toward her NOT with respect to the affairs, but with respect to how she is handling her end of the "deal" with respect to how we agreed to have the D-Bomb discussion with the kids.
-AlexEN
I don't expect her to do right by me at all; I still expect her to do what is right for the kids and will hold her to a much higher standard there...
-AlexEN
New: What a Weekend
H-48 WAW-49 M-22 S-14,9 D-11 EA disc.-11/07 PA disc.-3/08 EA2?-6/08 to ?
Thinking more about Sara's post (and her concern that W would walkaway from the boys, too) and trying to complete the picture of the weekend, I got a glimpse into her that I knew on an intellectual level, but had never truly "felt" before...
When we finally had a few moments away from the kids, I brought up that we had agreed not to go down the “adult problems” and “trying” path, but rather to focus on the kids' needs. Her defense (as in defense-mechanism) was that she thought I didn’t want to hear the words as the words would trigger the concerns I had with the going down that path.
She felt that by writing the words that it would somehow “different”. It was incomprehensible to me that she could be drawing such a fine line. But, I could see it in her eyes, she truly believed what she was saying and could NOT step into my shoes to see how there would be no difference between uttering the words and committing them to paper. She cannot NOT have her way; it is too firmly engrained. It is not, IMO, intentional. She "really" sees herself as the only truly aggrieved party. It is a built-in defense mechanism.
*****
Fast forward a little…
As I am changing, I notice she has left a book with notes in it in my underwear drawer. The book is “Helping Children Cope with Divorce” [the same book D11 saw her buy?] and she marked the pages she wanted me to read…
Quote:
“Please read this section. I don’t see how I deviated much from this example in the journals.”
“Researchers have found that having an explanation for the divorce they can understand helps children adjust, but most parents avoid these conversations… Many children and parents will later recall this as one of the most difficult experiences in their lives… children adjust better when parents give children explanations they can understand and repeated invitations to ask questions about what will happen and why.”
“I’m sorry if I used your trigger words. I’m begging you to help me not lose S14. If YOU go down the 'complete truth' path, I will likely lose S14 forever. If that happens, YOU might as well stab me for him because I will feel numb and worthless and forever depressed. If you’ve ever loved me, please don’t do this to me. Please try to feel where I am at right now. The pain of losing a child’s heart is very deep.”
@Sara, this is the most heartfelt language I have heard from her in years and years and why I believe she would never leave her boys.
She also highlighted the following section, which I think is her own self-fulfilling prophecy, because she keeps telling me I blame her, which I DO not. I only blame her for not having put an honest effort into seeing if the marriage could be saved – not knowing if it even could be saved:
“It is highly problematic for the child when one parent assigns blame for the divorce and communicates that the child should be angry with the parent who has left or should not respect, care about, or want to spend time with that person. Often this blame is assigned by inappropriately providing children with specific details of adult infidelities and sexual relationships…”
In her journals she had borrowed from the script this book suggests, even though it is not the one we had agreed upon… “Parents’ feelings about each other change as time goes by, and that is what happened to us…”
Perhaps to her credit (I say "perhaps" because of the apparent quid pro quo - she's sorry, but she's telling me it's up to me to save her R with S14). But, she's projected on me what she is hearing from S14 and, as a mother who loves S14, this outcome that she expected to come from me cannot really be coming from him, it HAS to be coming from me) she wrote in the margin, “I didn’t realize that what I wrote to them would upset you so much. My intentions were good.”
Yes, and I appreciate that, but her Actions and her Deed (this is for you @Smiley) were still inconsistent with what had been agreed upon.
@Puppy, this is when the Good Guy wanted to come to her rescue, but instead I told her it was not up to me to fight protect her relationship with S14... and that I don’t approve of his language toward her or his threats to his brother and sister and that I had talked to each one of them about that already... but he IS entitled to his own thoughts... and that I would no longer make any attempt to protect her from her own actions... and that she is responsible for the consequences of her own actions as am I for mine…
I told her I’d help her move to basement guest room and that I was not rushing her, but I need my space, too... that it won’t work for me if she’s moved to the guest room but has free access to come and go as she pleases from the master bedroom…
She still had to have the last word... saying "if I leave something in there it doesn’t mean I don’t want it when we go to divvy stuff up."
At that point I felt like Nick Nolte in the very last scene of North Dallas Forty and I let the ball drop.
New: What a Weekend
H-48 WAW-49 M-22 S-14,9 D-11 EA disc.-11/07 PA disc.-3/08 EA2?-6/08 to ?